2UE - Fairfax Radio Network

What we're talking about

Respect needed more than satire?

Posted by: 2UE | 22 September, 2012 - 6:00 AM
John Stanley on respect for religion and free speech

John Stanley looks at last week's riot in Sydney's CBD over some moron in the states putting out a clunky video. We need to be respectful, but does satire show a level culture has grown to through freedom of expression?

Stay up to date on breaking news with 2UE on Twitter  

Eleven males have now been charged over last saturday's rioting in the Sydney CBD.

It follows the arrest of a 19 year old male and a 16 year old at Bankstown .

The younger of the two has been charged with punching a member of the riot police in the face and also attacking a police dog.

He has been granted bail to face the children's court next month.

Muslim leaders call for calm

Australian Muslim men during Ramadan pray to Allah

Muslim leaders say they will not support any more protests in Sydney, urging police to arrest those who do not heed the call for calm. An additional 300 police officers will be out in force this weekend.

Multiculturalism: where are we going?

Who should carry the Australian flag at the Olympics?

Following the violent Islamic riots over the weekend there is a focus on where we are headed with multiculturalism. Jason Morrison with Dr. Peter Phelps on where we are headed as a multicultural nation.

Blog comments Your Say

  • When someone writes an article he/she maintains the idea of a user in his/her brain that how a user can be aware of it.
    Thus that's why this piece of writing is great. Thanks!

    Nagelpiz Bilder Friday 28 September, 2012 - 1:02 PM
  • "...how about I decide to dishonor them in the name of satire and then expect you to not be hurt. It makes no sense to hurt emotions of others and expect they do not react."

    That's what I was saying, YUSUF. If someone insulted my parents, for instance, it's highly unreasonable to except me to not respond. The question is, how do I react, and against whom?
    Other religions have been satired for decades, for instance by the likes of the late Dave Allen taking the mickey out of the Catholic church. He was an atheist, and can laugh at him any day.

    John has the right idea.

    Liberator Tuesday 25 September, 2012 - 9:12 AM
  • Dear Liberator

    Just because you find it funny does not mean others will too. There may be issues that are very close to your heart and you will be hurt if someone makes a mockery of them.
    Vast majority of Muslims do not believe in laughing at satires linked to other religions, thats not our values. We are taught mutual respect in the Quran and by our beloved Prophet Mohammed
    There is a difference in satire and hateful rubbish. I am sure you love your parents, how about I decide to dishonor them in the name of satire and then expect you to not be hurt. It makes no sense to hurt emotions of others and expect they do not react.
    Any action that leads to a dis-haromised society must be avoided. Peace and respect are more important that satire, speecially when it is intended to hurt and create tensions.


    I am shocked people like you still live in Australia, you need lessons on human decency and common sense.

    YUSUF Monday 24 September, 2012 - 11:39 AM
  • You're right, John.
    Every other religion in this country has copped a load of criticism and humor for a long time. In a free country, being critical of anything is something you need no-ones permission for. Of course, whilst each religion may take it on the chin, that doesn't they can't respond. That is THEY'RE right. If you're free to criticize, then you must feel free to BE criticized.

    Ironically, maybe we need things like this film this to bring out the true colors of a few people, muslin or not, and to say, "This is a free country. You are going to cop criticism. You are going to cop flack. Get with it."

    Liberator Sunday 23 September, 2012 - 11:13 AM
  • This much more balanced than that of some other commentators we heard from on 2UE and other stations.

    The key point is: Let not morons try to convince us that abuse of reverential figures, books and symbols of other faiths is "free speech"!

    Terrence Saturday 22 September, 2012 - 10:08 PM
  • "We need to be respectful."
    Whos "we"? Are you talking about the arab-muslims who have murdered, raped, bashed and stabbed hundreds of Aussies OR are you talking about Aussies who have called some people some bad names? And another thing, all this rubbish is a direct consequence of multiculturalism which we never asked for in the first place.

    Robert Saturday 22 September, 2012 - 2:32 PM

Post a comment * Mandatory fields